Symbols

Symbols in bulk solids technology

Overview of the symbols for calculations and measurements. Where EN 1991-4 uses a different symbol, it is given in the second column.

Silo calculation

Symbols for the design of silos to EN 1991-4

Symbol EN 1991-4 Unit Description
a - m Side length of a silo with rectangular or hexagonal cross-section
b - m Width of a rectangular silo
dc - m Characteristic dimension of the cross-section of the vertical silo section: dc = 4A/U
h - m Vertical depth below the transition
hb - m Total height of a silo from the virtual hopper apex to the equivalent surface
hc - m Height of the vertical silo section from the transition to the equivalent surface
hh - m Hopper height from the virtual hopper apex to the transition
ho - m Vertical distance between the equivalent surface and the lowest point of the solid surface (base of the surface cone)
z - m Depth below the equivalent surface of the solid in the filled condition
α - ° Inclination of the hopper wall to the horizontal (α = 90° − β)
β - ° Inclination of the hopper wall to the vertical; for rectangular hoppers β is the steepest wall angle
A - m² Horizontal cross-sectional area of the vertical silo section
U - m Internal perimeter of the cross-section of the vertical silo section
K - - Characteristic lateral pressure ratio: K = ph / pv (dimensionless)
ph - kN/m² Horizontal pressure of the stored solid at rest on the silo wall
pv - kN/m² Vertical pressure in the stored solid
φw - ° Wall friction angle on the vertical silo wall
μ - - Wall friction coefficient: μ = tan(φw) (dimensionless)
bmin - m Minimum outlet opening to prevent arching
DRH - m Rathole diameter to prevent ratholing

Yield locus

Symbols for yield locus and flowability, measured to ASTM D6682-A

Symbol EN 1991-4 Unit Description
σr — Pa Reference stress (pre-consolidation stress)
σN σN Pa Normal stress
σ1 σ1 Pa Major principal stress
σ2 σ2 Pa Minor principal stress
σc σc Pa Unconfined compressive strength
σt — Pa Tensile strength
σs,1 — Pa Major principal stress at steady-state flow
σs,2 — Pa Minor principal stress at steady-state flow
τc c Pa Cohesion (≙ c in EN 1991-4)
τrm — Pa Pre-shear stress
τm — Pa Shear stress at incipient flow
τs — Pa Shear stress at steady-state flow at normal stress
τs,c — Pa Cohesion at steady-state flow
ρb0 — kg/m³ Bulk density (loose)
ρbr — kg/m³ Bulk density (consolidated)
FL — - Flowability = σ1 / σc
FLR — - Relative flowability = (σ1 − σ2) / σc
FLA — - Absolute flowability = FLR · ρbr, relative to the density at consolidation stress
φi φc ° Angle of internal friction (≙ φc in EN 1991-4)
φe φi ° Effective angle of internal friction (pre-shear) (≙ φi in EN 1991-4)
φs — ° Angle of internal friction at steady-state flow
K0 λ0 - Coefficient of earth pressure at rest = σ2 / σ1
Km K - Mean lateral pressure ratio = 1.1 · (1 − sin φe) to EN 1991-4
R — - Correlation coefficient of the yield locus
Rs — - Correlation coefficient of steady-state flow

Wall friction

Symbols for wall friction, measured to ASTM D6682-B

Symbol EN 1991-4 Unit Description
σw - Pa Normal stress perpendicular to the wall surface in the wall friction test
τw,s - Pa Wall shear stress at static friction (start-up from rest)
τw,d - Pa Wall shear stress at dynamic friction
μs - - Wall friction coefficient at static friction: μs = tan(φs) (dimensionless)
μd μ - Wall friction coefficient at dynamic friction: μd = tan(φd) (dimensionless)
φs - ° Wall friction angle at static friction
φd φw ° Wall friction angle at dynamic friction
φx - ° Local wall friction angle: tan(φx) = τw / σw, slope of the straight line from the origin to the wall yield locus at the respective normal stress
τs - Pa Adhesion stress at static friction
τd - Pa Adhesion stress at dynamic friction

Bulk density

Symbols for bulk and compression density, measured to EN ISO 60 or ASTM D6682-C

Symbol EN 1991-4 Unit Description
ρb - kg/m³ Bulk density
ρb0 - kg/m³ Loose bulk density without mechanical compaction
ρ(σ) - kg/m³ Bulk density as a function of the consolidation stress
ρ(σ)Log - kg/m³ Logarithmic density function: ρ(σ) = b·ln(σ) + a
ρ(σ)Pow - kg/m³ Power function of the compression density: ρ(σ) = a·σb
RLog - - Correlation coefficient R of the logarithmic fit (dimensionless)
RPow - - Correlation coefficient R of the power fit (dimensionless)
CILog - % Carr compressibility index from the logarithmic function
HRLog - - Hausner ratio from the logarithmic function (dimensionless)

Angle of repose

Symbols for the angle of repose, measured to DIN ISO 4324 or ASTM D6393

Symbol EN 1991-4 Unit Description
φAR φr ° Angle of repose of a conical heap to DIN ISO 4324, determined as φAR = arctan(2hpeak / doutside)
hpeak - mm Vertical height of the cone tip above the base
doutside - mm Diameter of the circular base of the cone
φAR,avg - ° Arithmetic mean of n individual measurements of the angle of repose
SDAR - ° Empirical standard deviation of the angle of repose test series

Moisture content

Symbols for moisture determination by the oven-drying method or with a halogen moisture analyser

Symbol EN 1991-4 Unit Description
m0 — g Initial mass of the moist sample
mdry — g Dry mass after drying to constant mass
%M — % Moisture relative to the moist sample: %M = 100 · (m0 − mdry) / m0
%S — % Solids content relative to the moist sample: %S = 100 · mdry / m0
%Mdb — % Moisture on a dry basis: 100 · (m0 − mdry) / mdry
%Sdb — % Solids on a dry basis: 100 · m0 / mdry

Time consolidation

Symbols for the time consolidation of yield locus and wall friction

Symbol EN 1991-4 Unit Description
t — h Storage time under load (time consolidation)
f — - Time consolidation factor: ratio of the shear stress after the storage time to the shear stress without storage time (dimensionless, ≥ 1)
Δτc — Pa Increase in cohesion due to time consolidation: Δτc = (f − 1) · τ, where τ is the shear stress at the pre-shear point
σc,t — Pa Unconfined compressive strength after storage time
σc,t(σ1) — Pa Time flow function: unconfined compressive strength after storage time as a function of the consolidation stress
ffc,t — - Flowability after storage time: ffc,t = σ1 / σc,t
Δτc,w — Pa Increase in wall adhesion due to time consolidation on the wall

Referenced standards

  • EN 1991-4 – Eurocode 1: Actions on structures – Part 4: Silos and tanks
  • ASTM D6682 – Measuring Shear Stresses of Powders Using Rotational Split Level Shear Tester (A: yield locus, B: wall friction, C: compression density)
  • EN ISO 60 – Plastics – Determination of apparent density of material that can be poured from a specified funnel (bulk density)
  • USP 616 – Bulk Density and Tapped Density of Powders, Method III (bulk density)
  • DIN ISO 4324 – Surface active agents – Powders and granules – Measurement of the angle of repose
  • ASTM D6393 – Standard Test Method for Bulk Solids Characterization by Carr Indices (angle of repose)
  • USP 1174 – Powder Flow (classification by angle of repose, Carr index and Hausner ratio)